Madden & Finucane
the clients guide
to the legal profession
Chambers and Partners have been publishing their
world-famous guides to the legal profession since 1990. The key to the success
of their legal directories and the validity of their awards is the in-depth,
unbiased research conducted by their team of highly qualified and experienced
researchers. View more
Madden & Finucane
the Madden & Finucane
and Pat Finucane
The Aisling Bursaries, launched in March 2000, are
an educational initiative between Belfast Media Group and West Belfast
Partnership. The Aisling Bursaries are designed to help students defray their
education and training costs.
European Court of Human Rights case on assassinations
03 September 2009 --
THE families of two IRA Volunteers killed in a shoot-to-kill operation over 20
years ago are taking their case to the European Court of Human Rights. Martin
McCaughey and Dessie Grew were shot dead by the British undercore soldiers in
Loughgall, County Armagh, in October 1990.
No attempt was made to arrest either man despite the fact that both were
unarmed. Dessie Grew was shot 48 times and Martin McCaughey 12 times close to a
farm building near Lislasley. It later emerged that an IRA arms dump within the
building had been under surveillance and the RUC had prior intelligence that the
two men were due to visit. Over two decades later, inquests into the deaths have
yet to be held.
Since their deaths, the victims’ families have mounted a series of legal
challenges around the RUC’s failure to investigate the killings and the refusal
to hand over intelligence documents.
In 2001, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) ruled that the deaths of ten
other republicans had not been properly investigated. In 2007, the ECHR further
ruled allegations of collusion had also not been properly investigated.
Shortly afterwards, British law lords conceded that all police intelligence
files relating to the killing of Grew and McCaughey should be disclosed to the
coroner to allow the inquests to take place.
Speaking on behalf of the families, Fearghal Shiels, of solicitors Madden and
Finucane, said papers had been lodged with the European Court.
“The families contend that the state has clearly breached its legal obligations
to conduct an effective official investigation into the deaths of Martin
McCaughey and Dessie Grew.”
The solicitor said the RUC officers who investigated the killings lacked the
requisite degree of independence from the undercover soldiers involved in the
“No attempt was made to challenge the excessive force used, involving the firing
of at least 72 rounds and in circumstances where one of the men was shot twice
on the ground as he was dying or was already dead,” said Shiels.
“There was clearly no meaningful attempt made by the RUC to explore the
credibility of the accounts provided, failing even to re-interview the soldiers
in light of significant discrepancies.”
ONE OF A SERIES
The shooting was one of a series of ‘shoot-to-kill’ operations by the SAS in
which unarmed IRA Volunteers from Tyrone were summarily executed. In 1983, two
unarmed Volunteers died in a hail of 50 bullets, fired without warning, as they
arrived to check an arms dump in the Derrylaughlin area.
In 1984, the SAS were lying in wait as an unarmed IRA Volunteer crossed fields
at Ardboe. He was wounded in the legs but died from a single shot to the head.
Witnesses reported a burst of sustained fire followed by a single shot. At the
inquest a British soldier admitted shooting a man already wounded and lying in
In 1985, three IRA Volunteers died in a SAS ambush in Strabane. The Volunteers
were returning weapons, already broken down and sealed in plastic bags, to an
In 1987, eight IRA Volunteers were ambushed in Loughgall. All eight were killed
together with a civilian, Anthony Hughes, who was trapped within the SAS killing